Man jailed for nightclub rape

Jeremy Frazer Newsome Smith
Jeremy Frazer Newsome Smith

A cabaret artist who raped a 22-year-old woman during a hallowe’en party at a swingers’ club has been jailed for five years.

Jeremy Frazer Newsome Smith, 45, who was dressed as Herman Munster, attacked the woman in a mirrored indoor smoking room at sex club La Chambre, in the Attercliffe area of Sheffield, last October.

He denied rape and said the pair had consensual sex but a jury at Sheffield Crown Court found him guilty of rape after nearly seven hours of deliberations last month.

On Thursday Judge Peter Kelson QC jailed Smith for five years.

The court heard during the trial the woman went to the fancy dress party at the club with two female friends on October 27 and was dressed up as a vampire in a corset, stockings and heels.

Prosecutor Charlotte Baines had told the court the victim was a member of the Attercliffe club but never took part in any sexual activity and went there purely to socialise.

Smith, formerly of Tingley but now living in London, was also with friends - one dressed as Harry Potter and the other in drag as Lily Munster - and the trio had been asked to perform as the cabaret act for the night and were paid in drink.

Judge Kelson, who ordered the rapist’s name to be added to the Sex Offenders’ Register, said he accepted that the actions of the married father that night were “shockingly out of character’”

But he said rape was “a crime that leaves its victims nothing less than devastated”.

He said he had ‘wrestled’ since the start of the trial with the fact that Smith left the swingers’ club with his victim’s knickers after the attack.

“I wanted to know from the start whether it was because you were afraid that your DNA would have been on them and you took them away to conceal evidence, but that matter was never explored,” he said.

Judge Kelson said the impact the offence had on the victim was an ‘important’ consideration when sentencing Smith. He said she had been ‘drinking to excess’ since the rape.

Smith’s barrister, Karma Melly, said he was described by his wife as ‘respectful and gentlemanly’ and agreed the behaviour was out of character. “This behaviour on that night is not a real reflection of who Mr Smith is - it was borne out of a toxic combination of being in a place where sexuality and sex was paraded before him along with alcohol and viagra.”